A closer look at the connection between real product adoption and sustainable token value.
A well developed product may not result in a well performing token.
Why?
Despite implementing a successful product:
The price of the token may be struggling.
Image generated by ChatGPT
Why may this be happening?
Because just because a product is successful does not mean the value of the token will be high.
Why?
1. Users not requiring token
Suppose we have a blockchain solution offering very quick and cheap transfers of digital assets.
As this service is popular, we may be seeing increased numbers of transactions, and new users.
However, a problem may occur.
Users may not be required to own the project’s native token.
Users may make payments using stable coins or other cryptocurrencies.
Therefore, despite the product doing well, we may not see much demand for the project’s token.
Just because a project has a successful product, does not mean that it has a successful token.
If users don’t really have good reason to purchase/hold the token, then success of the product may not result in good token price.
2. Token has little purpose
All crypto tokens should have some clear purpose.
Whether this is paying transaction fees, staking, governing or allowing access to certain features.
However, having many functions within a token may not result in demand.
Suppose we have a governance token in place. However, most users may not participate in voting.
Therefore, although the token is present in the project, it may not be very significant.
In order for a project to be considered successful, users must have a clear reason to use the token.
Otherwise, it may be seen as just another crypto.
3. Too many tokens in circulation
Suppose the project had a large amount of tokens allocated to founders, investors and early adopters.
As time goes on, these tokens will be unlocked.
Suppose some of these token holders decide to sell their tokens.
Despite the product being successful, we may see increased selling pressure in the token.
Therefore, it is important to consider how many tokens exist, who they are allocated to, and when they are unlocked.
Even with a successful product, poor token economics within a project may cause issues.
4. Revenue within project may not benefit token holders
Suppose we have a crypto platform that is generating large amounts of revenue from transaction fees.
The business is growing, and we are seeing more people using the platform.
Where is this money going?
Is it being used to better run the business? Is it being sent into the protocol’s treasury? Or is it providing any direct benefits to token holders?
Despite generating large revenues within the project, this may not be benefitting token holders at all.
This means that just because a product is doing well, it does not mean that the token is performing well.
What should investors consider?
When considering investing in a project, apart from the product and price of the token, we should consider:
Does the token have value?
Do people require it?
Is the supply of token sustainable?
Are real users being attracted?
Is the growth in the product causing demand for the token?
These can enable you to determine if the token is adding real value to the ecosystem.
Final Thoughts
Although a crypto project may be extremely successful with a great product, gaining thousands of users, and solving real problems, if the token does not have a clear purpose, little demand, or poor token economics, then the token price may suffer.
Although a great product will create a great ecosystem, a great token design will require a reason to exist within the ecosystem.
Whilst they should work hand in hand with each other, great product performance does not guarantee great token performance.
What do you think? Should a successful crypto project automatically create value for token holders? Or should we consider the product and token separately?
Your Crypto Project Is Successful. So Why Is Its Token Struggling? was originally published in Coinmonks on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.
